Anomaly
I just finished watching the latest episode of Enterprise. It definitely continues to follow the "darker" trend that the producers have apparently set out to follow this season.
The episode itself was decent. Definite middle-of-the-road fare, when it comes to Trek. Any problems with it that I had weren't necessarily with the episode itself, but with the whole concept of the "The Expanse" itself.
Although I understand what the producers of Enterprise are attempting to do (bring an edgier feel to the series, something that was definitely lacking in the first two episodes), I'm not sure they are going about it in the correct way.
Consider the following (WARNING! I'm about to go really "Trekkie" here, so if you don't have the stomach for that kind of thing, tune out now): The Enterprise itself is only capable of Warp 5. This is a far cry from the Warp 9+ speeds of the Enterprise-D from Next Generation, right? This means that, the NX-01 is not capable of reaching the distances from Earth that the Enterprise-D traveled in any sort of reasonable time. Follow that?
So, what we have is a starship that isn't capable of traveling nearly as far from Earth as in "later" Star Trek series apparently entering an extremely dangerous area of space that we have never heard about before now. So, compared to the distances traveled in Next Generation, the Expanse must be relatively close to Earth. Since Earth is supposedly near the "heart" of the Federation in the 24th Century, doesn't that imply that there's a good chance that the Expanse would also be near the "heart" of the Federation? Why have we never heard of it before now?
The answer to that question, of course, points to one of the major problems with Enterprise itself: it's a prequel. The producers are trying to think outside the box and provide us with "new" concepts, yet maintain established (and limiting) continuity. This whole Expanse thing is a big change to that continuity that just doesn't fit in with what has already been established.
Now, I'm sure there are a million ways that they could eventually make it all work out (tonight's episode actually provided a few hints, I think, as to what they might do to still fit in with continuity), but that assumes that they'll actually follow through with that.
I'm also not sure that the whole "darker, edgier" concept will work well with Enterprise anyway. The Captain Archer that we saw tonight is a far cry from the Captain Archer that they established in the pilot episode two seasons ago. That Archer was full of wide-eyed wonder. This Archer seemed...bitter. I think I may have liked the wide-eyed wonder better.
Don't get me wrong, the series needed a change. It just wasn't clicking. But I'm not sure this is the way they should have approached the idea of adding an edge to the series.
The season is only two episodes old, however. Not nearly enough to judge it by, of course, so I will withhold judgment, but maintain my reservations. The two episodes (and tonight's episode, specifically), were good television. I just want to make sure that Enterprise stays true to original Star Trek philosophy.
Wow...this review definitely went in a direction I didn't expect. Huh. Okay..."trekkie" moment over. It's safe here again!