I've been doing some thinking regarding the system that Safari uses to organize bookmarks. I've been using Safari pretty much full-time for the last several months and generally like the browser. But, its bookmark system has been a bit of an enigma to me.
Ever since Safari premiered in its early public-beta version way back when, one of the features that has been touted to be better than all the other browsers is the way it handles bookmarks. It's been touted as revolutionary and the next stage in making browsers even easier to use.
Well, in the many months I have been using Safari part-time (and, as mentioned before, for the last several months full-time), I can honestly say this:
I don't get it.
Maybe there is something that I'm just plain missing, but I really just don't get what the hype is all about. I don't see what is so much better than before.
Perhaps I'm stuck in the past, but I've always been most comfortable accessing bookmarks through a menu in the menubar. Simply click the menu, and there are all your bookmarks for you to choose as you please. In early browsers, there was just one big list; a little later on, submenus appeared allowing people to categorize bookmarks. This just makes sense to me.
And, indeed, Safari offers this functionality. As I type this, Safari's "Bookmarks" menu is just sitting there waiting for me to tell it where to go next. It works as it always has.
What people seem to be excited about is the bookmarks button in the Bookmarks bar. Click that button and there, in your browser window is an iTunes-like display of all your bookmarks. But, again, I have to ask, what's the big deal about this? (Incidentally, the Bookmarks Bar is actually the best bookmarks innovation in Safari, in my opinion. I like the ability to have the pulldown menus in this bar for subcategories.)
To me, there are two different ways to approach this display. The first is as an organizer. This works, to me, very similar to the organizers found in other browsers such as Camino and IE. Create a new bookmarks folder and drag and drop bookmarks between folders organizing them as desired容ven reordering them, if desired. Indeed, in some ways, I find this to be more cumbersome than other browsers as well. Although, as I mentioned before, I really like the idea of the Bookmarks Bar, I don't like how much work it takes to have a pulldown menu of a subcategory of bookmarks appear in both the Bookmarks Bar and the Bookmarks menu, much less keep them synchronized once they are in their proper places? Why can't I just tell Safari to have this folder of bookmarks appear in both places, rather than having to maintain two identical sets of bookmarks? Perhaps there is a way to do this, but I'm simply missing it.
The second way to approach this display is as the user's primary way to access bookmarks. If you want to go to a bookmarked page, click the bookmarks button, find the bookmark you want and double-click on it. But this seems really cumbersome to me. Again, it just seems easier to select what I want from the "Bookmarks" menu (or a pulldown menu in the Bookmarks Bar). In fact, just to show that this isn't just some bias against Safari, I've always disliked this sort of method in other browsers as well (such as Netscape's Sidebar and similar interfaces found in Camino and IE). I'd just rather use the menu. It seems simpler.
Now, don't get me wrong, this is not a Safari-bashing rant. I really like Safari預 lot! But I just don't see the hype behind the bookmarks thing. But really, that's okay, I suppose. I've submitted feedback very similar to what I've written here to Apple. Maybe they'll pay attention to it, maybe not. But, at the very least, I can continue to use bookmarks as I always have and am most comfortable with: the "Bookmarks" menu. If the bookmark button works better for other people, that's fine too.